Journal of Cognitive Affective Learning
Home | Current | Archives | About | Login | Subscribe | Contact | Search
 JCAL Home > About the Journal > Editorial Policies open journal systems 

Editorial Policies

Focus and Scope
Section Policies
Peer Review Process
Publication Frequency
Open Access Policy


Focus and Scope
The Journal of Cognitive Affective Learning (JCAL)CEASED PUBLICATION MAY 2008. JCAL is a peer-reviewed journal dedicated to disseminating research on holistic educational practices that focus on the significance of the cognitive-affective relationship in promoting deep and enduring learning. *JCAL ceased publication in May 2008, but the archives are accessible through this journal site.*

Access to the journal is free of charge. JCAL published theoretical papers, original research reports, literature reviews, and extended reviews of selected books.

JCAL aimed to promote research, education, and community-building in the area of cognitive-affective learning. Our aims included:

--Identifying content and pedagogy of best Cognitive-Affective Learning (CAL) practices

--Defining and presenting the value and appeal of CAL to external academic and non-academic audiences

--Sharing instructional methods that support the Center for Cognitive-Affective Learning’s objectives

--Exploring ways to directly involve students as scholars in CAL Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) projects

--Disseminating CAL SoTL projects

--Utilizing JCAL as a community-building tool

SoTL projects for JCAL might well have included many already familiar to those engaged in the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning and to those desiring to do so:

· Theory Practice/Service Learning
· Active/Collaborative Learning
· Learning Communities
· Leadership Development
· Student Engagement
· Interdisciplinary Studies
· Multiculturalism
· Ethics and Social Justice
· Student Assessment/Portfolio Development

This resource was published via the Open Journal Systems (OJS), an electronic management and publishing system for refereed journals developed by the Public Knowledge Project. The OJS system provided comprehensive indexing of published articles using the Open Archives Initiative (OAI) protocol for metadata harvesting and as an OAI registered site will be broadly accessible as a part of global system of scholarly resources.

The journal will be archived for future scholars via the LOCKSS system (http://lockss.stanford.edu). The LOCKSS system was developed at Stanford University and is supported by Mellon Foundation funding. Emory University is an active participant in the LOCKSS project. The LOCKSS system has permission to collect, preserve, and serve this open access Archival Unit on the journal web site.




Section Policies
Articles
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Book/Media Reviews
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Literature Reviews
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Pedagogical Practices
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Student Perspectives
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Invited Papers
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Carnegie Leadership Communique
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
From the Editor
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 
 Editors:
 
Brief Reports
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 Submit brief report of proposed article.
 Editors:
 
Letters to the Editor
   Open Submissions
  Peer-Reviewed
   Indexed
  Research Support Tool
 Readers are invited to submit letters to the Editor that comment on articles published in JCAL. Letters written in a collegial and constructive manner, that offer reasoned criticism and further the discourse on the topic will be considered for publication in the next issue.
 Editors:



Peer Review Process
JCAL CEASED PUBLICATION MAY 2008. JCAL used a double blind, peer review process in which two reviewers were selected to perform an anonymous, in-depth evaluation of the submitted manuscript.

The Editor judged initially whether the submission was suitable for JCAL before assigning the manuscript to reviewers for peer review. The Editor selected the reviewers based on their expertise, reputation, and interest in the primary subject matter presented. Candidates were accepted to the review board based upon their proven publishing track record and/or upon recommendations from noted scholars and researchers in the area of higher education, learning theory, and scholarship of teaching and learning.

Additional peer review criteria included:

--Submissions must be recommended for publication by a minimum of two reviewers.

--If both reviewers provide contradictory recommendations, the Editor may assign an additional reviewer to “break the tie” and/or make the final decision on acceptance.

--Identity of the reviewers will remain anonymous and will not be disclosed to the author.

--The Editor will forward questions for clarification from the reviewers to the authors, but will keep these consultations to a minimum.

Reviewers made the following recommendations, based on submission criteria (originality, importance to scholarship of teaching, interest to wider higher education audience, solid methodology), peer review guidelines, and their expert, professional judgment:

1. Accept without revision

2. Accept with minor revision; does not require reconsideration by peer reviewer

3. Major revision needed; must revise and resubmit for reconsideration by peer reviewer

4. Not suitable for publication in JCAL

Peer Review Guidelines

Content:
Are data and facts free from error?
What are the main claims and are they significant to the scope and purpose of JCAL?
Does the organization and written style articulate clearly the article’s stated objectives?

Impact on Learning:
Does the article promote better understanding of teaching and learning in higher education?
Does it encourage and enliven pedagogical discourse?
Does it add value and usefulness to the enterprise of teaching and learning?

Value:
Does the article have theoretical or pedagogical value?
Does it add significantly to the emerging literature of cognitive-affective learning and the scholarship of teaching?
Does it illuminate our understanding of the connection between “the heart and the head” in deepening learning?

Research:
Does the article describe its objectives clearly?
Does it propose a detailed process for testing the effectiveness of its claims?
Does it explain the author’s research design, methods, and rationale clearly?
Does it accurately and comprehensively discuss the limitations of the research project?
Do the data and results support the article’s claims?

Integration:
Does the article integrate the research of others in a meaningful way?
Does it evaluate results and/or make recommendations for future exploration?
Does it incorporate aspects from a multicultural perspective?

Innovation:
Does the article propose innovative theories or pedagogies?
Does it alter our understanding of teaching and learning in novel ways?
Does it provide original and creative ideas based on results of research?

Inspiration:
Does the article inspire teaching excellence?
Does it encourage faculty, students, and staff to expand their engagement in the educational enterprise?
Does it incorporate subjective experiences (values, insight, experience) to illustrate a holistic learning process?

Additional review criteria:

1. Is there anything in the article that could give gratuitous offense or give cause for a libel action against the journal?
2. Are there any breaches of confidentiality
3. Are the illustrations, figures, and tables necessary/adequate?
4. Does the article require statistical review?





Publication Frequency
Semiannually (2 issues per year) CEASED PUBLICATION MAY 2008


Open Access Policy
Open Access Research


This journal provides open access to all of it content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge. Such access is associated with increased readership and increased citation of an author's work. For more information on this approach, see the Public Knowledge Project, which has designed this system to improve the scholarly and public quality of research, and which freely distributes the journal system as well as other software to support the open access publishing of scholarly resources.

The journal will be archived for future scholars via the LOCKSS system (http://lockss.stanford.edu). The LOCKSS system was developed at Stanford University and is supported by Mellon Foundation funding. Emory University is an active participant in the LOCKSS project. The LOCKSS system has permission to collect, preserve, and serve this open access Archival Unit on the journal web site.



Advisory Board Members

Randy Bass, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of English
Assistant Provost for Teaching and Learning Initiatives
Executive Director,
Center for New Designs in Learning and Scholarship (CNDLS)
Georgetown University
Pew Scholar, 1998-1999
Carnegie Scholar, 1998-1999

Daniel J. Bernstein, Ph.D.
Professor of Psychology
Director of the Center for Teaching Excellence
University of Kansas
Carnegie Scholar, 1998-1999

Barbara Cambridge, Ph.D.
Senior Program Officer, National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE)
Consultant, Carnegie Academy for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (CASTL)

Robert L. DeHaan, Ph.D.
Senior Science Advisor,
Department of Educational Studies
Candler Professor of Cell Biology, Emeritus
Emory University

Martin Halbert
Director of Systems
University Libraries
Executive Director,
MetaScholar Initiative (http://metascholar.org)
Emory University

Patricia Owen-Smith, Ph.D.
Professor of Psychology and Women's Studies
Coodinator,
Center for Cognitive-Affective Learning
Oxford College of Emory University
Carnegie Scholar, 2000-2001

Mariolina Salvatori, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of English
University of Pittsburgh
Editor,
Reader: Essays in reader-oriented theory, criticism, and pedagogy
Carnegie Scholar, 1999-2000

Gretchen Schulz, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Humanities
Oxford College of Emory University
Advisory Board, Emory Center for Ethics
Emory Univ. Advisory Council on Teaching
Georgia Governor's Teaching Fellow, 2000








Peer Review Board Members


Burhan Akpinar, Ph.D
Lecturer of Education Faculty
Firat University

Cynthia Alby, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Secondary Education
Georgia College and State University
Georgia Governor’s Teaching Fellow, 2001-2002

Olivia Archibald, Ph.D.
Professor of English
St. Martin's University

Susan Ashmore, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of History
Oxford College of Emory University

Mohamed Ben Ammar
REsearch Group on Intelligent Machines (REGIM)
University of Sfax, ENIS

Curtis Bennett, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Mathematics
Loyola Marymount University

Debra Coffey, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Elementary and Early Childhood Education
Kennesaw State University
Editor, Taking Teaching and Learning Seriously (http://ttls.dragteck.com)

Jodi Cressman, Ph.D.
Director, Office for Teaching, Learning, and Assessment
DePaul University

Mary Ann Danielson, Ph.D.
Interim Associate Vice President for Academic Affairs
Interim Director, Office of Academic Excellence and Assessment
Associate Professor of Communication Studies
Creighton University

Donna Engelmann, Ph.D.
Professor of Philosophy
Past President, American Association of Philosophy Teachers (as of January 1, 2007)
Alverno College

Terence (Terry) Favero, Ph.D.
Associate Dean of Curriculum
Professor of Biology
University of Portland

Tara Fayter
Service-Learning Coordinator
Richard Stockton College of New Jersey

Maura Flannery, Ph.D.
Professor of Biology
Director, Center for Teaching and Learning
St. John's University (New York)
Carnegie Scholar, 2000-2001

Linda Gabriel, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor
Vice Chair of Occupational Therapy Department
Creighton University Medical Center

Barbara Gayle, Ph.D.
Academic Vice President
Viterbo University
Carnegie Scholar 2001, 2006
Associate Editor, Women‘s Studies in Communication
Treasurer, International Society for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning
Editorial Board Member, Communication Monographs

Sarah M. Ginsberg, Ed.D, CCC-SLP
Coordinator, Div. 10/
Higher Education American Speech-Language-Hearing Association
Associate Professor
Dept. of Special Education
Eastern Michigan University

James Hall, Ph.D.
Director, New College
University of Alabama

Maureen Hall, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Education
University of Massachusetts Dartmouth

Lawrence Hanley, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of English
City College of the City University of New York

Rosemary Lehman, Ph.D.
Senior Outreach/Distance Education Specialist
Instructional Communication Systems
Manager, Instructional Design Team
Award for Excellence in Leadership and Distance Education
University of Wisconsin-Extension

Sharon Lewis, Ph.D.
Professor of Psychology
Association for Psychological Science Fellow
Oxford College of Emory University

Kenneth Lynch
Senior Lecturer
University of Gloucestershire (Cheltenham, UK)

Timothy McGettigan, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Sociology
Colorado State University-Pueblo

Kathleen McKain, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of French
St. Martins University

Marlene Moore, Ph.D.
Dean, College of Arts & Science
Professor of Biology
Culligan Medal Recipient, 1987
University of Portland

Tom Ott
Professor of English
Director, Developmental Education
Community College of Philadelphia

Patricia Owen-Smith, Ph.D.
Professor of Psychology and Women's Studies
Coodinator,
Center for Cognitive-Affective Learning
Oxford College of Emory University
Carnegie Scholar, 2000-2001

Gregory G. Passmore, Ph.D. CNMT
Associate Professor
Medical College of Georgia
Georgia Governor’s Teaching Fellow, 2000

Heather Patrick, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Chemistry
Oxford College of Emory University

Steven Pyser, J.D.
Associate Faculty, Business and Management
University of Phoenix (Greater Philadelphia Campuses)
Scholar Practitioner, Fielding Graduate University’s Dialogue, Deliberation and Public Engagement Certificate Program, 2005, 2006.
Managing Editor, Journal of Public Deliberation
Associate Editor, Group Facilitation: A Research and Applications Journal
Editorial Board/Advisory Panel, International Journal of Public Participation (IAP2)
Editorial Board Member, Conflict Resolution Quarterly
Staff Editor, The Journal of Legal Studies Education

Eileen Reilich, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Education
Saint Martin's University

Jeffrey Sapp, Ph.D.
Professor of Education
California State University, Dominguez Hills

Gretchen Schulz, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Humanities/English
Oxford College of Emory University
Advisory Board, Journal of Cognitive Affective Learning
Advisory Board, Emory Center for Ethics
Advisory Board, Emory Center for Women
Emory University Advisory Council on Teaching
Resident Scholar: Atlanta Shakespeare Company
Georgia Governor’s Teaching Fellow, 2000

Theodosia Wade
Senior Lecturer, Biology
Oxford College of Emory University

Beverly Wallace, Ph.D.
Acting Assistant Director of Writing Support
Academic Programs and Services
Shippensburg University

Joyce Westgard, Ed.D.
Dean, College of Education
St. Martin’s University

Isa Williams, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Women's Studies
Director, Experiential Learning & Atlanta Semester Program
Agnes Scott College











Home | Current | Archives | About | Login | Subscribe | Contact | Search

Journal of Cognitive Affective Learning. ISSN: 1549-6953


The LOCKSS system (http://lockss.stanford.edu) has permission to collect, preserve, and serve this open access Archival Unit on the journal web site.